Welcome

Lets talk Beyond the Sound Bite. Welcome to BSB chat!

Tuesday, December 20, 2011

The Great American Debate

This past week, ABC aired 'The Great American Debate" on the program "This Week: with Christiane Amanpour". The Debate was Moderated by Amanpour and sought to resolve the question "What is the proper Role of Government?" The guest debaters on the program were Rep. Paul Ryan and ABC's George Will who represented the political Right and Rep. Barney Frank and Former Labor Secretary Robert Reich speaking for the Left. The Video of the debate is broken up into 3 segments and the links for all three are posted below. I watched this debate and was quite fascinated by much of the arguments presented by both sides and thought it was a great idea to posts this to the blog. I would encourage everyone to watch it when you have time and feel free to comment on what you felt were the most pertinent points of contention as represented by debaters. Enjoy!
 
Part 1:
http://abcnews.go.com/ThisWeek/video/great-debate-part-15182994?tab=9482931&section=2808950&playlist=2808979

Part 2:
http://abcnews.go.com/ThisWeek/video/great-debate-part-ii-15183015?tabID=9482931&sectionID=2808950&playlistID=2808979

Part 3

http://abcnews.go.com/ThisWeek/video/great-debate-part-iii-15183113?tab=9482931&section=2808950&playlist=2808979

Sunday, December 4, 2011

Dont take your eye off the ball!! Income inequality is a threat,,

The concept known as priming and diffusing is a media and political tactic. Simply put, priming refers to messages created to emphasize a particular viewpoint, and defusing refers to messages created to de-emphasize another. For instance, A candidate might prime the elctorate by consistently speaking on the economy if the candidate feels their econmic background is a strength. Im sure you can surmise a contrary scenario to define diffusing then. 

Today, this tactic is is being used by many conservative commentators on the issue of income inequality. To be clear, I am certainly not speaking ill of conservatives for implementing this tactic being that some of my own views are conservative. However, trying to diffuse an issue like income inequality comes as no surprise if the prevailing paradigm is that the countries conservative party shills for the upper class.  This is precislely why the priming of this issue is usually brought about by more liberal news outlets given that the anger aroused would more than likely be beneficial to Democrats. To the contrary, the conservatives have been vehemently trying to diffuse the concern over the wage gap by either not talking about it , or redirecting anger for it towards Obama. Well, no matter where you stand on the ideolgical spectrum, the fact is that this issue should not be one that is diffused because of the tremedous risk to our countries survival. We have already been warned...
--REVOLUTIONS arise from inequalities, numerical or qualitative--from a numerical mass claiming an equality denied them, or from a minority claiming a superiority denied them. A revolution may result either in a complete change of polity, or only in a modification of the existing one. An oligarchy is less permanent than a democracy, owing to factions within the oligarchical body.
-Aristotle
I could go on and on with scientific evidence but there is an abundance of data out there in the more recent years to conclude that Income inequality is detrimental to society.  Although it may not be the sole factor of societal decay, it is a major factor nonetheless. Thus, any notion that economic inequality is not a problem is a view that is squarely in the minority of social scientific thought. As a result, the rest of this post will operate on the assumption that inequality is a definite problem. So what now? It’s pretty obvious that the Occupy movement is struggling with that question themselves but one thing they do know is that something has to change.

Monday, November 28, 2011

GOP: The Real Compromisers and Champion of Jobs

I really hope that this past week makes everyone realize how much Liberals love to lie to you. The prevailing mesaage offered by the left is that Republicans do not want to compromise,and that we are the party of no. Well I certainly hope that 'THE REAL AMERICAN JOBS BILL" will put these rumors to rest! The bill which is sponsored by Johnny Issakson,Rand Paul and John McCain seeks to do so much to aid this economy. Things like drilling off shore, lowering historically low tax rates and ending regulations(you know...new ideas). Now when we come out and say that we are willing to work with the president, maybe people will start believeing us since the number of  Democrat ideas included in this plan numbers in the,,,um,,,well it doesnt have any Democrat ideas but thats not the point. A better example of the willingness of the Right to work for jobs is the recent bill Republicans passed in the House called the Protect Life Act which passed 251-172. The Act would ban women from being able to use any insurance coverage that is subsidized by the Presidents health care law that happens to cover the cost of abortions even though the Hyde amendment already bans it. The amount of jobs this creates is right around... well not many. Ok OK bad example.   The point of that bill is really to call attention to the need to repeal the job killing health care law that requires a mandate for insurance. Republicans know that it wont work. Look at the Republican front runner Mitt Romney's state of Massachussetts. His mandated health care state has the most covered children in the country...so..that means..um...you know what forget it. Let me just close with this: Tax Breaks,tax breaks,drill,drill, god, guns, Obama is a communist.  Vote Republican!! 

Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Herman Cain....I just dont get it

I pride myself on my ability to find redeeming qualities in people who I fundamentally disagree with. But Herman Cain....I just don't get it??? Someone one asked me why once because they were a Cain supporter themselves, but my reasons are really pretty simple.
               
Substantively, I disagree with his flat tax approach among other things. I’m more of a proponent of the Mitt Romney tack. Lower rates, plug loop holes for the wealthiest to generate revenue, and provide tax cuts to the middle class. 9-9-9 and plans like it decrease revenue in my estimation and burden the middle class too greatly. However, I think much more of my disdain for the man has to do with the fact that he exudes an ora of ignorance. Whether it be his comments that he’ll just say I don’t know when he’s asked who is the leader of “Uz-beke-beke-stan”,( which I took as a clear derogatory characterization of a region where we have a lot of problems right now), to his glaring inability to keep up mentally when an interviewer asks him a question about Libya. Now let’s be clear, I’m not buying into the whole,” Herman is stupid” narrative based off that interview. I’m sure he can articulate a stance on Libya given time. But time to contemplate is a luxury that a President does not always have. (cue the phone call at 3am ad) The man just doesn’t seem up to the task to be president and I frankly don’t see the “charisma” some people are apparently drawn too. Hence my statement, Herman Cain….I just don’t get it…

Foreign Policy: The Wrong Time for Cowboys

The world has undoubtedly changed since the conclusion of the Cold War in the late 80's. Prior to that, the United States was facing an enormous empire in the Soviet Union that was armed with thousands of nuclear weapons. To the average American, the only real way to exert influence around the world -- a world that just saw two World Wars, a Korean War and Vietnam -- was based on the assumption that we had to have the superior military might. Another way of saying it is that we were used to "Hard Power" being the model for foreign policy. However, something else was happening in the penultimate stage of the Cold War. The United States was incorporating several international institutions and fostered cultural and academic exchanges. Then the internet came which launched the information age. The world was connecting, globalizing, and the changes that took place to the US and its counterparts going into the early and mid nineties were astounding. To be more specific though, 5 post cold war trends were outlined in an article in Foreign Policy Magazine by Joseph Nye. The world saw increasing:
  •  economic interdependence
  • a growth in transnational actors
  • nationalism in weak states
  • the spread of technology
  • changing political issues
Looking at this list, it almost certain that no one would disagree that Nye’s prognosis was correct. So now that this new paradigm is in full effect, what then should the goal be for global dominance? After all, the struggle for power is the ultimate goal of world politics.  During the Cold War the emphasis by foreign policy administrators was centered on a reliance on hard power (and understandably so). But we now live in a different world and Nye argues that while an up to date military is not totally unecessary, the new focus should not be on intimidating other countries with military muscle so that they will follow us. To the contrary, concentrating on our ability to manipulate foreign states to a greater extent through control of the political and economic environment should be the emphasis. Essentially, incorporating soft power. What do you think Iran is doing right now? Sure you hear about their Nuclear program and veiled threats to move ships off of our coast. But you also constantly hear about how Iran is pulling international strings. They're working behind the scenes in the Middle East infiltrating Iraq, Pakistan, and Syria, and exerting their soft power. But Iran, by all measures, is losing in that game because of multilateral pressure led by the West; not in the forefront but behind the scenes in a war being covertly waged. Moreover, and not to the surprise of anyone who might read my blog, I believe that this fight is being taken to Iran off stage through the policies of Obama and Clinton. (Hillary of course)  Now I understand that the criticism is that Obama is not leading but rather leading from behind. Well I agree, however, with one caveat: He is leading from behind.... the scenes!   As for the critics of my assessment, I think the following is the best way to drive home the overarching point. It comes from an article in the New Yorker.  
"The trouble with so much of the conservative critique of Obama’s foreign policy is that it cares less about outcomes than about the assertion of America’s power and the affirmation of its glory. In the case of Libya, Obama led from a place of no glory, and, in the eyes of his critics, no results could ever vindicate such a strategy. Yet a calculated modesty can augment a nation’s true influence. Obama would not be the first statesman to realize that it can be easier to win if you don’t need to trumpet your victory."
The time has come for smart power and not the cowboy , cognitive consistent approach that some might have you believe... 

Sunday, November 6, 2011

Lead from Behind or Behind the scenes?

While I’m no fan of the Libyan invasion, I must say that the Obama Doctrine as its being called worked. I find it interesting though that the criticism of Obama from the Right is that the United States did not play a leading role. Seriously? NATO cant wipe there %*@ without the US so to suggest that we played no role from the beginning falls flat with me. But nevertheless, I think there might be a deeper reason for the criticism aside from the obvious political election season. It was best summed up in an article in the New Yorker when the author, David Remnick, wrote "The trouble with so much of the conservative critique of Obama’s foreign policy is that it cares less about outcomes than about the assertion of America’s power and the affirmation of its glory. In the case of Libya, Obama led from a place of no glory, and, in the eyes of his critics, no results could ever vindicate such a strategy."
For the full article you should check it out at this link. Happy Reading!!
  

Iraq? Afghanistan? Pakistan? Uganda?:Maybe its time we mind our own business?

“The great rule of conduct for us, in regard to foreign nations, is in extending our commercial relations, to have with them as little political connection as possible. Europe has a set of primary interests, which to us have none, or a very remote relation. Hence, she must be engaged in frequent controversies the causes of which are essentially foreign to our concerns. Hence, therefore, it must be unwise in us to implicate ourselves, by artificial ties, in the ordinary vicissitudes of her politics, or the ordinary combinations and collisions of her friendships or enmities”
-- George Washington
 These words served to embody the spirit of Isolationism that has a long history in the United States. It was until the Spanish-American War that the United States was officially established as an imperial power given its subsequent acquisition of the Philippines and Guam which occurred primarily in direct response to the Monroe Doctrine policy enacted in 1823 Not surprisingly, this was also the first example of where interventionism served to cause greater problem for the US than solution. While The US promptly defeated Spain, it lead to the Philippine-American War or The Philippine war of independence.
Nevertheless, today and in the past 100 years, we have seen an unprecedented amount of American action overseas. Much of this meddling was in defense of the American form of government: Democracy. While I do not dispute that Democracy is the best existing form of governance implemented by any society, it is important to recognize the building blocks of what makes a democracy a democracy. Few would disagree democracy was best summed up in the Gettysburg address by the line that we are all taught as children. Democracy is a government  “of the people, by the people, and for the people.” While this is a well known phrase, those who are proponents of democratizing foreign sovereign nations fail to see the logical contradiction they are espousing. How can a nation truly have a democracy if it is not one born of its people?
The phrase does not say that a democracy is by the American people, for your people, and of our people. It is for this reason perhaps that democracy implementation, which no one argues has been successfully created by the United States, came with such a price.  For example, in order to bring democratic government to Germany, Italy and Japan the United States had to conquer and occupy foreign territory, grant generous economic assistance, and defend the new governments from external threats. Furthermore, it came only after having to endure a World War. The United States itself had to fight its own civil war to obtain democracy and yet still have not perfected the system after 200 years in existence.  This is all to say that counting the cost of interventionism has not been done so fairly.
I've heard all the arguments like if democracy could be implemented in non-democratic nations that it would ultimately create a ally in the newly liberated country. The fact of the matter is that democracy is only as good as the people it is given to.  Democratic governments rule by the consent of the people, however, it is not always the case that the interests of the people are synonymous with American interests.
Then there is the minimalists argument that says if perhaps we only defended new democracies that formed on their own we would spend less money and wouldn’t be beholden to their future conflicts. that’s just not the case. Let’s look at the countries that we actually did spread democracy. In Germany, Japan and Italy, three things had to be done in order to maintain stability: substantial foreign aid, a complete invasion of a sovereign territory, and defense thereafter of that territory. It is quite evident that without these three elements, it will put the newly democratized country at greater risk due to its inherent fragility. The vulnerability of new democracies have numerous examples which would contradict any claim that nascent States can thrive sans American contribution. Case in point is the reversion taking place in Russia’s democracy that is illustrated by the Freedom House  downgrade to “not free” in 2006. Four military coups suffered by the people of Thailand further lends credence to the weakness new governments. Lastly, the coup d’état that ended the Fijian democratic project is another evidentiary factor. You really think we are not going to be involved in Libya after all that? The bottom line is that I think that Ron Paul has gotten this one right. Bring our troops home and lets deal with our own problems. The world cop thing is getting old..

Monday, October 24, 2011

Don’t EVEN Get Me Started, Mythical Bootstraps College Student

Recently I saw a photo that has gone viral several times over.  The photo shown belowe is of a college student who apparently is pulling herself up by her bootstraps through some extraordinary measures. While I dont typically write about what I see on Social Media, this assertion that anyone can acheive what this student is allegedly accomplishing is pervasive among certain political segments. I think this photo, and the attention it is getting, really distorts reality and I'm very glad that someone took the time to point it out.

Just for the record , this is obviously not my work but thought it should be shared nonetheless. Check this great article out!

Wednesday, October 19, 2011

Media: Four times More Negative in Obama Coverage

This blog post is not to answer the question of whether there is a liberal bias in the media. In actuality, its purpose is to do what BSB Chat promises to try and accomplish in its name: Chat Beyond the Sound Bite. Which sound bite you might ask? “Biased media coverage helped Obama win the White House” While the election is a long way off and the last elections coverage of Obama is still hotly debated by both sides,  the following article talks about a study done of the media in this most recent election cycle by the Pew Research Group. The Study was released this past Monday and shows that among all the Candidates, Obama was 4 times as likely to receive negative coverage than any other candidate. Now, to be fair, Obama is the president and the economy plus the candidate attacks on him do count in the negative column. However, as I said earlier, this is not designed to answer the question of the existence of liberal bias. The fact is negative coverage is negative coverage no matter what the reason and the Media has a choice as to whether or not to air it or print it. Thus, while the campaigns are still in the early stages, it’s important to preemptively nullify any claims that the media is helping or hurting any candidate out of ignorance or prejudice towards the media in general. I'll be the first to admit that I have my ideas of who gets the most negative coverage, but this article shattered most of my preconceived notions. Did you know that Sarah Palin, the "lame stream media" basher in the flesh, is a leader in the most positive coverage category only second to Rick Perry? Check this article out or if you prefer, go directly to the study. Very interesting stuff....   

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

Christie out, Now What?

Its apparent to me that the Republicans are very dissatisfied with their current field. Chris Christie said in a press conference the other day that he would like to think that the push to get him to run was more about who he was as a governor and less about a referendum on the Republican field. Well I tend to disagree with the Governor. Nevertheless, the Republicans are stuck with the field that they have and as far as that goes, I really don’t know why the media is making such I big deal about Rick Perry’s gaff during the debate. It is true that his poll standings have diminished substantially but I think people are counting him out way too early. Again, I think that this is a definite influence of the media. The fact of the matter is that Rick Perry has tremendous support with the evangelical right. and history has shown that they are a very powerful lobby among the Republican base. Also, the TEA party has many Evangelical members among it ranks as well. So while everyone is clamoring about Mitt Romney, I think that they should look out for the Texan who has never lost a race. Anyone who counts him out yet is naïve.

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

Not Anti-Israel, Just Pro Common Sense...

So I’ve been having a feud with a friend of mine and his older brother has been trying to mediate it. It seems that no matter what the older brother is always asking me to make concessions and my complaints about my friend falls on deaf ears. After all, one of the parties(not me) has a brother mediating this dispute.  So  really, what incentive do I have to cooperate?
 This crude and simplistic analogy is how I see the relationship  between Israel, Palestine, and the US. ( Hopefully this doesn’t insult anyone’s intelligence but the US and Israel are the brothers in this analogy, and Palestine is the disgruntled third party.) To be more specific, I think this is how the relationship has been defined prior to the Obama Presidency. But now, it seems like not only is Palestine being held accountable but so is Israel for their constant  settlement construction.  It just makes sense to me. You can support Israel while simultaneously being an objective arbitrator. I think this is the best strategy but it’s disappointing to me when the Republicans continue to lambast the president for being anti-Israel. Granted it’s an election season and I’m sure it makes for great politics but I find this to be different from other political fights. I don’t think our foreign policy during sensitive times in history should be politicized for the sake of an election. After all, countless Israeli officials completely disagree with the notion that Obama does not stand with Israel. I’ll be the first to admit that I am in no way proficient in middle eastern affairs so I write this from a position of humility. That being said, if you disagree with my assessment and no more about the history that might refute my opinion, please let me know!   Can’t wait to hear what you think!

Friday, September 9, 2011

Speech Gate

                       
                              
Jon Stewart made an interesting point the other night that really calls into question whether the media can be fair arbitrators. An amicable solution to a scheduling conflict between Obama's speech and the GOP debate was turned into "Speech-Gate: the Cowardice of a President" We are in huge trouble if every little thing is going to be magnified to the extent that FOX and CNN took it. It's strange though because the media is always being accused of having a liberal bias. Here we have a clear case of Barack Obama being attacked for what was presented as him backing down or being weak in negotiations with the GOP. Thus, this leads me to believe that, at least in this instance, perhaps it’s not so much that the media has its attention set to bolster liberal view points but rather to bolster spectacle. The truth is that we all have our biases no matter what, however, the media at the end of the day a business. While some networks like MSNBC may do more to paint liberal perspectives in a better light, even they wouldn't back down from negative depictions of a democratic president that might garner ratings. What do you think?

Friday, September 2, 2011

Obama Tea Party Downgrade?

Recently, with the downgrade of America's credit rating in the news, pundits have been encouraging the blame game in every way they can. It would have been hard to turn on the televisions with out hearing the drama of the how the tea party hijacked congress or how the reason we are in this predicament is due to Obama's outrageous spending. While there is only a modicum of truth to either claim, the branding attempts by both sides of this situation really caught my interest. I remember turning on the television and within 1 hour i heard John Kerry and Roland Martin refer to it as the "Tea Party Downgrade" on CNN, and countless conservative talking heads refer to it as the "Obama Downgrade". I barely heard anything about the reckless spending of every other president and congress that brought us to this point to begin with. The fact is the media (more so the televised sort) doesn't bother to disseminate the facts because they know people are going to hear what they want to anyway.
Case in point is a conversation I had with my sister in law, who is so conservative she glows red and probably has a full back elephant tattoo. She posted to her facebook a scathing post about how Obama walked away from the debt ceiling deal all because he wanted to tax more at the last minute. Thus, the failure to come to a bargain was ultimately his fault. But over the 9 months the negotiations were taking place, I found it very interesting that the very first instance of someone walking away from the table she quotes is Obama. Of course, me being the seeker of truth i am, I took the initiative to remind her of Tom Coburn and John Kyl walking out on Biden and Eric Cantor walking on the gang of six.
In any case, The point is simple. The media doesn't really need to play fair because that's not what will get it ratings. I only hope the public will wake up and start to at least look at multiple forms of media in order to get a rounded and equal grasp of future situations. Partisanship within the news business is alive and kicking.