Welcome

Lets talk Beyond the Sound Bite. Welcome to BSB chat!

Wednesday, November 23, 2011

Foreign Policy: The Wrong Time for Cowboys

The world has undoubtedly changed since the conclusion of the Cold War in the late 80's. Prior to that, the United States was facing an enormous empire in the Soviet Union that was armed with thousands of nuclear weapons. To the average American, the only real way to exert influence around the world -- a world that just saw two World Wars, a Korean War and Vietnam -- was based on the assumption that we had to have the superior military might. Another way of saying it is that we were used to "Hard Power" being the model for foreign policy. However, something else was happening in the penultimate stage of the Cold War. The United States was incorporating several international institutions and fostered cultural and academic exchanges. Then the internet came which launched the information age. The world was connecting, globalizing, and the changes that took place to the US and its counterparts going into the early and mid nineties were astounding. To be more specific though, 5 post cold war trends were outlined in an article in Foreign Policy Magazine by Joseph Nye. The world saw increasing:
  •  economic interdependence
  • a growth in transnational actors
  • nationalism in weak states
  • the spread of technology
  • changing political issues
Looking at this list, it almost certain that no one would disagree that Nye’s prognosis was correct. So now that this new paradigm is in full effect, what then should the goal be for global dominance? After all, the struggle for power is the ultimate goal of world politics.  During the Cold War the emphasis by foreign policy administrators was centered on a reliance on hard power (and understandably so). But we now live in a different world and Nye argues that while an up to date military is not totally unecessary, the new focus should not be on intimidating other countries with military muscle so that they will follow us. To the contrary, concentrating on our ability to manipulate foreign states to a greater extent through control of the political and economic environment should be the emphasis. Essentially, incorporating soft power. What do you think Iran is doing right now? Sure you hear about their Nuclear program and veiled threats to move ships off of our coast. But you also constantly hear about how Iran is pulling international strings. They're working behind the scenes in the Middle East infiltrating Iraq, Pakistan, and Syria, and exerting their soft power. But Iran, by all measures, is losing in that game because of multilateral pressure led by the West; not in the forefront but behind the scenes in a war being covertly waged. Moreover, and not to the surprise of anyone who might read my blog, I believe that this fight is being taken to Iran off stage through the policies of Obama and Clinton. (Hillary of course)  Now I understand that the criticism is that Obama is not leading but rather leading from behind. Well I agree, however, with one caveat: He is leading from behind.... the scenes!   As for the critics of my assessment, I think the following is the best way to drive home the overarching point. It comes from an article in the New Yorker.  
"The trouble with so much of the conservative critique of Obama’s foreign policy is that it cares less about outcomes than about the assertion of America’s power and the affirmation of its glory. In the case of Libya, Obama led from a place of no glory, and, in the eyes of his critics, no results could ever vindicate such a strategy. Yet a calculated modesty can augment a nation’s true influence. Obama would not be the first statesman to realize that it can be easier to win if you don’t need to trumpet your victory."
The time has come for smart power and not the cowboy , cognitive consistent approach that some might have you believe... 

No comments:

Post a Comment