“The great rule of conduct for us, in regard to foreign nations, is in extending our commercial relations, to have with them as little political connection as possible. Europe has a set of primary interests, which to us have none, or a very remote relation. Hence, she must be engaged in frequent controversies the causes of which are essentially foreign to our concerns. Hence, therefore, it must be unwise in us to implicate ourselves, by artificial ties, in the ordinary vicissitudes of her politics, or the ordinary combinations and collisions of her friendships or enmities”
-- George Washington
These words served to embody the spirit of Isolationism that has a long history in the United States. It was until the Spanish-American War that the United States was officially established as an imperial power given its subsequent acquisition of the Philippines and Guam which occurred primarily in direct response to the Monroe Doctrine policy enacted in 1823 Not surprisingly, this was also the first example of where interventionism served to cause greater problem for the US than solution. While The US promptly defeated Spain, it lead to the Philippine-American War or The Philippine war of independence.
Nevertheless, today and in the past 100 years, we have seen an unprecedented amount of American action overseas. Much of this meddling was in defense of the American form of government: Democracy. While I do not dispute that Democracy is the best existing form of governance implemented by any society, it is important to recognize the building blocks of what makes a democracy a democracy. Few would disagree democracy was best summed up in the Gettysburg address by the line that we are all taught as children. Democracy is a government “of the people, by the people, and for the people.” While this is a well known phrase, those who are proponents of democratizing foreign sovereign nations fail to see the logical contradiction they are espousing. How can a nation truly have a democracy if it is not one born of its people?
The phrase does not say that a democracy is by the American people, for your people, and of our people. It is for this reason perhaps that democracy implementation, which no one argues has been successfully created by the United States, came with such a price. For example, in order to bring democratic government to Germany, Italy and Japan the United States had to conquer and occupy foreign territory, grant generous economic assistance, and defend the new governments from external threats. Furthermore, it came only after having to endure a World War. The United States itself had to fight its own civil war to obtain democracy and yet still have not perfected the system after 200 years in existence. This is all to say that counting the cost of interventionism has not been done so fairly.
I've heard all the arguments like if democracy could be implemented in non-democratic nations that it would ultimately create a ally in the newly liberated country. The fact of the matter is that democracy is only as good as the people it is given to. Democratic governments rule by the consent of the people, however, it is not always the case that the interests of the people are synonymous with American interests.
Then there is the minimalists argument that says if perhaps we only defended new democracies that formed on their own we would spend less money and wouldn’t be beholden to their future conflicts. that’s just not the case. Let’s look at the countries that we actually did spread democracy. In Germany, Japan and Italy, three things had to be done in order to maintain stability: substantial foreign aid, a complete invasion of a sovereign territory, and defense thereafter of that territory. It is quite evident that without these three elements, it will put the newly democratized country at greater risk due to its inherent fragility. The vulnerability of new democracies have numerous examples which would contradict any claim that nascent States can thrive sans American contribution. Case in point is the reversion taking place in Russia’s democracy that is illustrated by the Freedom House downgrade to “not free” in 2006. Four military coups suffered by the people of Thailand further lends credence to the weakness new governments. Lastly, the coup d’état that ended the Fijian democratic project is another evidentiary factor. You really think we are not going to be involved in Libya after all that? The bottom line is that I think that Ron Paul has gotten this one right. Bring our troops home and lets deal with our own problems. The world cop thing is getting old..
No comments:
Post a Comment